Skip to main content

Star Trek: TOS 'Mudd's Women' 60th anniversary (Redshirts retro review)

A con man, a beauty pill, and three women daring to rewrite the script.
Star Trek: The Original Series courtesy of Titan Books
Star Trek: The Original Series courtesy of Titan Books | Star Trek: The Original Series courtesy of Titan Books
2 of 6

1. Harry Mudd as a charismatic, grubby face of the frontier

Harcourt Fenton Mudd (Roger C. Carmel) arrives fully formed as one of Trek’s first recurring rogues: a cheerful con man, serial liar, and walking labor dispute who somehow never stops being entertaining. He’s not a grand villain; he’s the sleazy underside of the Federation frontier, the guy who exploits gaps in the system to make a profit off people’s desperation.

That energy still plays. Mudd’s fast-talking self-interest, his faux respectful patter with authority, and the way he treats the women as inventory rather than people make him easy to root against without ever making the episode feel grim.

In a modern rewatch, he reads as an early example of Trek admitting that “boldly going” also attracts grifters, traffickers, and people who see the final frontier as one big marketplace to be gamed. At the end of the day, though, the character of Harry Mudd is beloved by many fans, thanks in large part to Carmel's performance.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Loading recommendations... Please wait while we load personalized content recommendations