Skip to main content

Star Trek: TOS 'Mudd's Women' 60th anniversary (Redshirts retro review)

A con man, a beauty pill, and three women daring to rewrite the script.
Star Trek: The Original Series courtesy of Titan Books
Star Trek: The Original Series courtesy of Titan Books | Star Trek: The Original Series courtesy of Titan Books
4 of 6

3. The Venus drug, beauty, & the limits of the metaphor

The sci-fi twist, that Mudd’s “stunning” companions are using a Venus drug to enhance their beauty and charm, is the core of the episode’s metaphor. Strip the drug away, and they’re framed as “ordinary” or even “plain." Take it again, and they light up the room and scramble men’s common sense, including Dr. McCoy’s.

The closing idea, that one woman can will herself beautiful without the pill, is Trek trying to argue that real attractiveness comes from self-belief and inner strength rather than chemical enhancement. It’s clumsy, and the message gets undercut by how much time the camera spends objectifying them anyway.

However, the germ is still interesting in 2026: a story about how systems convince women they must chemically or cosmetically alter themselves to be worthy of affection or stability. Watching it now, you can see an early attempt to address insecurity and social pressure through sci-fi allegory, one that stumbles, but at least aims in the right direction.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Loading recommendations... Please wait while we load personalized content recommendations