Skip to main content

Star Trek's Sherlock Holmes actors react to beloved characters & their MTG cards

“I had always wanted to play Sherlock; it was a dream come true.”
BySteven Thrash
“I had always wanted to play Sherlock; it was a dream come true.”
“I had always wanted to play Sherlock; it was a dream come true.” | CBS Photo Archive/GettyImages

“I had always wanted to play Sherlock; it was a dream come true.”

Collectable card games will never be the same now that Magic: The Gathering | Star Trek has pulled a Reese's Peanut Butter Cups and combined the best of the sci-fi and CCG worlds. And while promoting the new Trek edition of MTG, actors Brent Spiner and Daniel Davis not only got the opportunity to see their Sherlock Holmes and Professor Moriarty cards, but they also took the time to reflect on two of The Next Generation’s most memorable holodeck characters.

“I had always wanted to play Sherlock; it was a dream come true,” Spiner revealed in a video posted to Magic: The Gathering’s official Instagram @wizards_magic, which fans can watch in its entirety below. “We had no idea that here, 30-something years later, those episodes are iconic,” Davis added.

“I’m always stunned at how attractive he is,” Spiner joked while checking out his Magic: The Gathering | Star Trek Lt. Commander Data card. “I'm thrilled about this.”

“Oh my God,” Davis reacted as he first glimpsed his Magic: The Gathering Moriarty card (“Adversary by Algorithm”) from the new Star Trek collectible card game. “I’m astonished. Pardon me, I’m just kind of stunned […] I’m just completely in awe. I look good [laughs].”

It’s hard to believe nearly 40 years have passed since Data first stepped onto the USS Enterprise-D’s holodeck to play the part of the world’s greatest detective, Sherlock Holmes, in The Next Generation season 2 episode “Elementary, Dear Data.”

For me, one of the most fascinating elements from “Elementary, Dear Data” is the dilemma that Data must face in that classic Next Generation episode. Holmes' lifelong nemesis, Moriarty, was only meant to be a character in a holodeck mystery. However, Moriarty evolves and becomes a self-aware being.

Believing himself to be a real person, Moriarty fears for his life once the holodeck simulation ends. So, should or shouldn't Data end the program?

This is an excellent storytelling twist, not to mention character study, as it mirrors Data’s own argument that he is a sentient lifeform, not just an android, which would play out in The Next Generation’s “The Measure of a Man” installment later that very same season.

The popularity of “Elementary, Dear Data” ensured that Holmes (Spiner) and Moriarty (Davis) would face off again, which they did in The Next Generation season 6 episode “Ship in a Bottle.” And I was utterly delighted when Davis was invited back to reprise the role in Star Trek: Picard for the streaming series' third and final go-round.

For more Star Trek content and to share your thoughts on the Sherlock Holmes and Moriarity Magic: The Gathering cards, visit the Redshirts Always Die Facebook and X pages to sound off in the comments.

Live long and prosper, Trekkies!

Add us as a preferred source on Google