Honorable mention: the Duras Sisters
Generations' secondary adversaries, Lursa and B'Etor, the cunning Duras Klingon sisters, work with Soran. The Next Generation villains were fun to watch, and they die explosively after destroying the Enterprise-D in the film.
The late Barbara March and her co-star Gwynyth Walsh play the sisters with scenery-chewing pleasure, Lursa (March) with snarling ambition, B'Etor (Walsh) with weaponized sexuality. Though not the main threat in Generations, their presence adds Klingon intrigue and completes their multi-episode corruption and revenge arc.
Final Verdict
The TNG movie villains are a mixed bag, ranging from the franchise-best Borg Queen to the disappointingly flat Shinzon. What separates the great from the mediocre is clear: the best villains have personal connections to our heroes, coherent motivations, and commanding performances that elevate the material.
The Borg Queen had all three. Soran had two. Ru'afo had one. And Shinzon, despite Hardy's efforts, had none that translated successfully to screen. Still, even the lesser TNG movie villains gave us memorable moments, proving that while the films themselves varied in quality, the Enterprise crew always faced adversaries worth remembering, for better or worse.
For more Star Trek content, visit the Redshirts Always Die Facebook and X pages.