Skip to main content

Star Trek: TOS 'Charlie X' 60th anniversary (Redshirts retro review)

A dangerous boy, a trapped starship, and the cost of saying no.
Star Trek: The Original Series courtesy of Titan Books
Star Trek: The Original Series courtesy of Titan Books | Star Trek: The Original Series courtesy of Titan Books
5 of 6

4. Kirk as moral teacher & reluctant parental figure

“Charlie X” also offers an intriguing glimpse of James T. Kirk beyond captain and action hero. Here, he’s positioned as Charlie’s primary role model, the adult whose approval the boy craves and whose behavior he tries to imitate. That dynamic makes Kirk something like an unwilling father figure, tasked with teaching morality to someone who can rewrite reality whenever he’s displeased.

The episode doesn’t pretend this is easy. Kirk isn’t instantly wise or perfectly patient; he misreads Charlie at first and underestimates the danger. But once Kirk understands what he’s dealing with, his approach isn’t just to outmaneuver Charlie tactically.

Kirk tries to explain why certain behaviors are unacceptable, why desire doesn’t confer ownership, and why living among others demands self-control. His “you don’t have the right” attitude toward Charlie’s use of power is as important as any strategy on the bridge.

Kirk is shown as an admirable leader who recognizes that setting an example of accountability is just as important as giving orders. Kirk is not just trying to defend his ship; he's trying to convince a child that just because you can do something doesn't mean you should.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Loading recommendations... Please wait while we load personalized content recommendations