Skip to main content

Recollection: A Star Trek Story episode 1 (Redshirts review)

Episode 1 delivers a stylish, mystery-driven opening filled with sharp artwork and promising character tension.
Attach your combadge and get ready for the return of Captain Jean-Luc Picard with Star Trek: Picard premiering on CBS All Access Jan. 23.

Combadge
Attach your combadge and get ready for the return of Captain Jean-Luc Picard with Star Trek: Picard premiering on CBS All Access Jan. 23. Combadge | USA TODAY Network via Reuters Connect
3 of 3

1. Storytelling

Recollection episode 1's biggest strength is how well it handles its mystery. Writer Sam Maggs doesn’t rush to explain everything right away. Who is this woman with amnesia? Why is she on a Federation ship? And why can’t she remember how she got there?

Instead of immediately answering those questions, the story lets the protagonist, and the reader, sit in that confusion. It creates a tense, almost claustrophobic feeling that keeps you wanting to know more.

That makes Recollection a strong fit for the serialized WEBTOON format. The first chapter gets the premise across without dumping too much information on the reader. We quickly understand that the woman with amnesia is isolated, vulnerable, and unsure if she can trust JAID.

However, at the same time, the story leaves nothing but unanswered questions to make you want to keep reading and find out what happens next to this woman who has lost her memory.

The Federation setting, which takes place "in a later timeline inspired by Star Trek: The Next Generation and Voyager" (per WEBTOON's official Instagram), adds another layer to the mystery. A Federation starship is normally associated with safety, exploration, and cooperation.

Putting a group of confused, amnesiac passengers — yes, the mystery woman is destined to find six others in future episodes — inside a Federation ship immediately makes that familiar setting feel unsettling. The mystery isn’t just about what happened to these people. It also makes us question whether the environment they’re in can actually be trusted.

That’s a strong hook for Star Trek fans, especially with the larger story pointing toward a mystery involving people who are supposedly being sent to a reeducation facility.

Recollection starts with an engaging mystery, excellent visual storytelling, and a woman whose missing history is already becoming the story’s most interesting feature. Episode 1 does not reveal everything, and it is better for that restraint: it gives readers a reason to return as the passengers, and the audience, begin putting the pieces together.

For more Star Trek content and to share your comments on Recollection episode 1, visit the Redshirts Always Die Facebook and X pages.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Loading recommendations... Please wait while we load personalized content recommendations