Why does First Contact outscore Wrath of Khan with critics?
People typically praise First Contact for its cinematic scope, fast pace, and engaging antagonist (the Borg). This lets The Next Generation cast shine in their finest feature. Jonathan Frakes' direction, a fusion of tension, blockbuster action, and franchise loyalty, appeals to critics seeking a modernized Trek adventure that doesn't alienate newcomers. For many, Frakes' movie is the best "entry-friendly" and well-made Next Generation movie. It has high stakes, emotional depth (Picard's horror with the Borg), and unforgettable set pieces.
In contrast, Wrath of Khan is a slow-burn character drama from the 1980s that people appreciate and often laud for its themes of death, age, and revenge. Older fans and critics of the show loved it, and it is still praised for its sharp script and memorable villain. However, newer reviews occasionally say that the tempo or look of the show is out of date compared to other Trek shows. (Continued...)