Star Trek: Starfleet Academy is poised to tackle one of Deep Space Nine’s biggest unresolved questions: what really became of Captain Benjamin Sisko after the series finale, “What You Leave Behind.” A visual in the upcoming show's teaser trailer and fresh comments from showrunner Noga Landau suggest that the fate of Benjamin Sisko will move from haunting background mystery to on-screen text — and possibly even story.
Landau highlighted Sisko specifically when talking about how Starfleet Academy will honor 60 years of Star Trek legacy. She said while speaking at this year's New York Comic Con (via ScreenRant):
"And there's also mysteries. Watch out for Benjamin Sisko! We get to do some really cool stuff that hasn't been done in a long time, that I think really honors the fans who've been waiting to see what happens. So we definitely know who we are and the shoulders that we are standing on today."
Combined with that promise, her remarks strongly imply the series will do more than name-drop Sisko and will treat his fate as a real narrative thread for longtime Deep Space Nine fans. DS9 ended with Sisko sacrificing his physical life to stop Gul Dukat and the Pah-wraiths in the Fire Caves, then existing as a spiritual being with the Prophets in the Bajoran Wormhole.
In a final vision, Sisko assured his wife, Kasidy Yates, that he would return leaving fans debating whether that promise meant a literal homecoming, a metaphysical reunion, or something in between, and for over 25 years, tie-in novels and fan theories have tried to answer that question while on-screen canon stayed silent.
The Starfleet Academy teaser trailer changed that dynamic, showing the hologram cadet SAM (Kerrice Brooks) standing in front of a museum-style display titled “The Fate of Benjamin Sisko, Emissary of the Prophets,” which frames Sisko as a case study in confronting the unexplainable.
Starfleet Academy is set in the late 32nd century, hundreds of years after Sisko’s disappearance in the 24th, yet how will the show handle the mystery? The screen SAM observes in the teaser trailer presents two statements which ponder whether Sisko died in the Fire Caves of Bajor, or whether he lived in The Celestial Temple.
For a new generation of cadets, Sisko could be a historical puzzle and spiritual paradox, embodying Trek’s tension between science, faith, and the unknown, and that gives the series a lot of freedom: it can simply codify his fate in lecture form or going further and actively involve the Prophets, and possibly Sisko himself, in the cadets’ story.
Avery Brooks has largely stepped away from acting, so a full physical return as Benjamin Sisko is uncertain, but the franchise has many ways to honor Sisko without recasting him or undermining DS9’s ending, from archival imagery and visions to new revelations about his time with the Prophets.
And whatever form it takes, Landau’s comments and the teaser’s imagery hopefully mean Starfleet Academy intends to confront the question head-on and finally give Sisko’s long-suspended promise to return some kind of canonical resolution.
For more Star Trek content, visit the Redshirts Always Die Facebook and X pages.