Skip to main content

SFA's series debut is way better than its poor rating (and this is why)

Star Trek: Starfleet Academy’s series premiere proves its critics wrong with heartfelt character work, sharp Trek lore, and five standout moments that go way beyond a 5.8 rating.
L-R: Robert Picardo as The Doctor, Kerrice Brooks as Sam and Bella Shepard as Genesis in season 1 , episode 1 of Star Trek: Starfleet Academy streaming on Paramount+. Photo Credit: Brooke Palmer/Paramount+
L-R: Robert Picardo as The Doctor, Kerrice Brooks as Sam and Bella Shepard as Genesis in season 1 , episode 1 of Star Trek: Starfleet Academy streaming on Paramount+. Photo Credit: Brooke Palmer/Paramount+
4 of 7

3. SAM and The Doctor: holograms with history

The premiere’s most quietly Trek‑core material comes from the interplay between SAM, the bubbly photonic cadet, and The Doctor, now a long‑lived EMH who has literally outlived almost everyone he’s ever known.

SAM has been alive for only four months yet is programmed to be 17, all nerves and overeager friendliness; The Doctor is over 800 years old, wryly quoting his own catchphrases while visibly wincing at reminders of the Voyager and Prodigy crews.

Their corridor conversation is a generational handoff in Trek's hologram canon, not just nostalgia. SAM gushes about his service history, naming Dal, Murf, and “Captain Gwyndala,” while The Doctor shifts the discussion, showing the loneliness of remembering everyone.

Behind laughs about aging subroutines and “Please state the nature of the medical emergency,” the episode gently asks what it means for a sentient program to bear centuries of anguish and couple him with a new hologram who hasn't even started to understand that weight. Because it expects you to think about it, low user scores reduce nuanced, continuity-savvy storytelling into “fan service”.

Add us as a preferred source on Google

Loading recommendations... Please wait while we load personalized content recommendations