Why 5.8 stars misses the point
A 5.8 average on IMDb says more about the climate around NuTrek than the craft of this specific episode.
There’s documented frustration over “soapy” elements and franchise fatigue, and threads in Trek fandom openly wrestling with how much of the low scoring is coming from coordinated negativity versus viewers engaging with the story on its own terms.
Look at the actual work: this is a 75‑minute pilot that feels intentional in its pacing, invests in a multi‑species, multi‑generation cast, integrates legacy characters like The Doctor without turning them into mascots, and gives its core cadets memorable, character‑defining beats in their very first hour.
That’s not the profile of a 5.8‑star shrug; it’s the foundation of a series that, like its chancellor, is already more interesting, and more resilient, than its reputation.
For more Star Trek content, visit the Redshirts Always Die Facebook and X pages.
Add us as a preferred source on Google