4. Now is the right time
Each season so far has deepened our understanding of Pike’s crew, blending classic adventure with character-first storytelling. But by season 4, the series risks revisiting familiar tones unless it takes a bold creative swing. The Mirror Universe is that swing. It offers high drama, legacy resonance, and a canvas for the actors to explore radically different versions of their roles, a proven formula in Trek history.
While The Next Generation and Voyager are beloved; neither series ever delivered a true Mirror Universe episode on television, leaving a tantalizing what‑if hanging over both crews.
Moreover, after Discovery’s emotionally heavy treatment of the Mirror Universe, Strange New Worlds could recalibrate it to match its lighter, more adventurous tone. It wouldn’t need to wallow in darkness; instead, it could use contrast to remind audiences why the Federation’s ideals matter in the first place.
At least fans did get to see beloved Voyager characters like Admiral Janeway (Prodigy), Tuvok (Deep Space Nine), and Captain Chakotay (Prodigy) on the other side of the mirror in different series. But what about SNW? Are we going to end up with those season 4 puppets instead of a Mirror Universe?
If Strange New Worlds wants to continue honoring Star Trek’s tradition of moral reflection wrapped in daring adventure, there’s no better story realm to explore next. Season 4 should let us look into that ruthless, glittering reflection once again, and remind us why the light of the Prime Universe shines so brightly.
For more Star Trek content, and to share your thoughts/comments on a Strange New Worlds Mirror Universe, visit the Redshirts Always Die Facebook and X pages.