Fans have debated the greatest moments in Star Trek: The Original Series for decades, but when it comes to picking the best episode, there’s a recurring champion, “The City on the Edge of Forever.” This classic episode, a masterclass in science fiction television, isn’t just beloved, it’s the gold standard for everything Star Trek aspires to be: thoughtful, courageous, and deeply human.
Emotional depth rarely seen in science fiction
From the episode’s opening act, “The City on the Edge of Forever” quickly establishes the gravity of its story. Dr. McCoy wanders into a time portal called the Guardian of Forever and is sent to Earth in the 1930s. His accidental plunge through time sets off a chain of events that causes the Allies to lose World War II and the Federation to never exist. This brings Captain Kirk (William Shatner) face to face with the ultimate Trek dilemma: to save the future, he must sacrifice personal happiness.
Kirk's love for Edith Keeler (Joan Collins) makes the daring captain seem more vulnerable. Rather than brushing past heartbreak, the episode forces the conflicted captain and us to confront the agony of moral responsibility. The iconic scene where Kirk is forced to stop McCoy from saving Edith's life in a traffic accident is one of the most painful human moments that has ever been broadcast on sci-fi television.
Genre-Defining drama and storytelling
Before this episode, Star Trek was mostly pulpy adventure stories and social commentary. "The City on the Edge of Forever" takes things to a whole new level by using science fiction to craft a story that is both dramatic and funny.
Harlan Ellison's script (even though there were problems behind the scenes and rewrites) is all about fate and free choice, two concerns that would come up in sci-fi for decades.
The Guardian of Forever's chilling presence makes the universe feel even bigger, but the risks are very personal. This delicate balance between universe-threatening consequences and intimate tragedy is rarely accomplished on television, let alone network sci-fi of the 1960s.
Timelessness and Influence
What makes "The City on the Edge of Forever" last? It touches on matters that everyone can relate to, such as love, grief, consequences, and the need to make sacrifices. You don't have to be a Star Trek fan to understand Kirk's sadness or to appreciate the philosophical challenge faced by Mr. Spock and McCoy. Modern sci-fi, whether on Doctor Who, The Expanse, or even newer iterations of Star Trek, draws upon the blueprint established here: bold ideas entwined with relatable characters.
Many episodes of TOS are recognized for their playful imagination, iconic lines, or social relevance, but none marry heart and science fiction as poignantly as “The City on the Edge of Forever.” It’s this synthesis that keeps the episode at the peak of best-of lists and in the hearts of fans. Plus, the chemistry between Kirk and Keeler is undeniable thanks to the well-written script, not to mention Collins and Shatner's authentic acting in their shared scenes.
Not only is "The City on the Edge of Forever" an amazing Star Trek episode, but it's also a great piece of television and a significant milestone for sci-fi. It is still remembered not just because it was the first or the flashiest, but also because it made people think about responsibilities and passion, having the future of mankind depend on the grief of one starship captain. That, more than any technobabble or starship battle, is why it remains the best TOS episode ever made nearly sixty years after its debut.
Do you agree with our pick? Share your favorite Star Trek: The Original Series episode with us on the Redshirts Always Die X and Facebook pages.