Every December, A Christmas Carol inevitably makes its round -- in theaters, on TV, on streaming, and in arguments over which version “counts.” There are flashier adaptations, funnier ones, and versions more eager to chase easy warmth.
But for viewers who grew up with Star Trek: The Next Generation — and learned that the best stories often hinge on moral reckoning rather than spectacle — Patrick Stewart’s 1999 A Christmas Carol remains the gold standard thanks largely to the actor's indelible performance as the classic Charles Dickens' character.
Stewart didn’t come to Ebenezer Scrooge lightly. Years before the film, he performed A Christmas Carol as a one-man stage show, inhabiting every role himself. That matters. Much like Stewart’s gradual ownership of Jean-Luc Picard over the course of TNG, this is a performance built on deep familiarity with the text and character, and trust in language over theatrics.
What’s especially striking is how Stewart’s Scrooge feels like a deliberate inversion of Picard. Where Picard repeatedly chose engagement — whether confronting regret in the TNG episode “Tapestry” or rediscovering a lifetime of connection in “The Inner Light” — Scrooge chose isolation at every turn. This wasn't villainy for its own sake; it was emotional withdrawal hardened into philosophy. It was a choice. Trek fans will recognize the difference immediately.
The classic ghosts functioned much like the best TNG narrative devices: as catalysts, as mirrors. Christmas Past (played by Joel Grey, who had guest-starred in “Resistance,” a 1995 episode of Star Trek: Voyager) forced Scrooge into something akin to Picard’s reckoning with roads not taken in “Tapestry."
Christmas Present carried the quiet moral clarity of episodes like “The Drumhead,” where self-justification crumbled under scrutiny. And Christmas Yet to Come landed with the cold inevitability of a final captain’s log — no grandstanding, just consequence.
Like the top-drawer episodes of The Next Generation, this adaptation of A Christmas Carol trusted its audience to sit with discomfort. It didn't rush Scrooge’s transformation or soften the cost of his choices. Redemption here wasn't a switch flipped for applause; it was a hard course correction, closer to Picard’s humbling moments than a holiday miracle.
Is this the coziest Christmas Carol ever filmed? Absolutely not, but Stewart's performance elevates this adaptation to must-see status. Those watching the film will appreciate the character-driven storytelling, ethical turning points, and Stewart doing what he’s always done best.
A Christmas Carol (1999) earns its place in the seasonal holiday rotation thanks to Patrick Stewart's must-see performance. Think of it as The Next Generation Christmas episode we never got: no warp drive, no starship, just one man forced to confront the life he’s lived — and the future he’s charting — before it’s too late.
For more Star Trek content, visit the Redshirts Always Die Facebook and X pages.